Tuesday, October 30, 2007

When gender plays a role in your connection to the students

In my theory class, I have two boys (both sophomores) in my class. One of them has a 504 plan, the other does not. One boy has an incredibly bad attitude and is a bully towards other students. He does OK in theory, but he is having a hard time understanding the concepts of minor scales. When I approached him about it and asked him when he was available to come in for extra help he snickered at me and blew me off. I figured that he was just getting frustrated and that I would give him a day to cool off. So, I approached him later in the week, because he was still confused, and he ignored me and mumbled comments under his breath. So I looked up his 504 and saw that he has a tracking teacher whom is in charge of him when problems arise. I went to the tracking teacher, told her my issues with him, and she said, "no matter what you do you won't succeed because you're a woman. He gives all of his female teachers a hard time. He doesn't listen to me. I don't know why they assigned him to me. They should have assigned him to a male tracking teacher since he responds better to men." My student never turns in homework and doesn't participate in class. When I assign class work and I walk around the room to check on peoples work, this particular student takes his hands and covers up his work so I can't see it. I don't know what to do. I can't change my gender. My co-op basically told me that there's nothing I can do. When I ask for advice everybody tells me, "you can lead a horse to water but you can't make it drink." I'm so sick of hearing that. I have to find a way to make the horse drink, but in a different way. I feel that I'm at a complete standstill though, because it's my gender that's the issue and not my ideas or teaching. Does anybody else have a student like this? Does anybody have any advice?

2 comments:

Kate Campe said...

I think this is a really interesting situation. I have a similar student in one of my classes with out a 504 so there is very little guidance on how to reach him. But in this case you have a idea of what the problem is. You are right in the fact that you can not change who you are, maybe what is necessary for him, is to relearn the ideas of respect for all people, male, white, black, purple etc. If your co-op is male I would suggest having your co-op speak to him. If not, possibly enlist in the help of a male principal? Here is the main problem that must be fixed, If this student does not learn to respect women now, what will happen down the road to his future girlfriends, wife and or children? I agree with you that you must find a way to reach him, but not because he needs to learn music theory, but because he needs to understand respect.

Kettlebell Lady said...

you did not mention what was on his 504. What modifications did it list for him?